A year ago at this time, the Chicago Bulls appeared to be building their future around playmaking guard Josh Giddey. Giddey looked the part of a nightly triple-double threat and even began to score with volume that put him on the cusp of All-Star status. Unfortunately, not everything he showcased appears to be sustainable.
With new franchise player Caleb Wilson sidelined after undergoing surgery on his hand, the Bulls must learn what Giddey's limitations truly are and come to terms with what they may mean for his future with the team.
At his best, Giddey offers a bit of everything on the offensive end of the floor. That was on display during the first half of the 2025-26 season, as he averaged 19.2 points, 9.0 assists, 8.9 rebounds, 0.9 steals, and 1.9 three-point field goals made on .466/.386/.761 shooting through Chicago's first 41 games.
Giddey's scoring fell rather precipitously from thereon out, however, as he averaged 14.3 points, 9.3 assists, 7.5 rebounds, 1.1 steals, and 2.0 three-point field goals on .420/.341/.768 shooting between the Bulls' final 41 games.
Injuries likely played a factor, as Giddey appeared in 54 games, with 30 during the Bulls' first 41 outings and 24 between their second 41. Chicago also seemed to have priorities other than winning, which may have impacted his quality of play.
In saying that, Giddey is currently averaging 10.4 points, 8.5 assists, 5.3 rebounds, and 1.3 threes on .416/.326/.640 shooting in 2026-27. Chicago needs to figure out if this is the type of scorer he is.
Which version of Josh Giddey's scoring is actually sustainable?
The good news is that Giddey's playmaking appears to be a lasting strength. His court vision and accuracy as a passer at 6'7" have translated to dynamic angles and crisp feeds finding players in ideal positions to put points on the board.
The question about Giddey, however, is whether or not he can score at a high enough level to actually be an offensive hub or if Chicago needs to find him a more strictly defined role.
If Giddey bounces back as a scorer and the former thus proves true, then the Bulls can comfortably run their offense through him. That would help simplify the game for Wilson, who's the team's leader in field goal attempts but is more of a scorer than an all-around playmaker.
The Bulls could then organize their system to prioritize Giddey's playmaking while trusting that he can make teams pay when they give him space as a shooter or challenge him to drive.
Is Josh Giddey an offensive hub or just a playmaker who can't defend?
If Giddey continues to struggle as a scorer, however, then the Bulls' path to finding him the ideal role could prove challenging. His playmaking ability will still have value, but given that he's a subpar defender, it'd be difficult to justify starting-caliber minutes for him beyond this season.
The Bulls' options are limited in 2026-27 and Giddey has helped Wilson improve his true shooting percentage by 18.4 percent when they've shared the court, but after this year, they may need to look elsewhere.
In the plainest of terms: Chicago can't have a point guard who can't stop his opponent from scoring if he can't put up points himself. His passing can help, but he at least needs to be able to shoot with a high degree of efficiency and volume if he's going to have two weaknesses in shot creation and defense.
It may seem harsh considering how much Giddey has contributed to the Bulls since his arrival in 2024, but if he can't fix either his scoring or his defense, then his tenure may run out sooner than later.
